Hard landings

June 6, 2011 by Tim McAdams

The recent media coverage of the damaged military helicopter left at the compound where Osama bin laden was killed has peaked questions about what causes a hard landing. Although, I have witnessed (and performed myself) some landings that were pretty rough, I consider a hard landing as impacting the ground hard enough to cause damage or require an inspection. Due to the sensitive nature of military operations just what caused the hard landing in Pakistan might never be known for sure, but here are a few of the common causes.

In flight training a common cause of hard landings is poor timing at the bottom (the part near the ground) of a practice autorotation. If the autorotation is intended to touch down or power is brought back in too late, the flare height and pitch pull timing are very important. If performed incorrectly, the helicopter can touch down with enough force to spread the skids, cause the main rotor blades to contact the tail boom or roll over. Most of the time these are preventable and no one is hurt (egos maybe). In a real autorotation, options might be very limited and damaging the helicopter while sustaining no injuries would be considered a successful autorotation.

Exceeding the helicopter’s performance capabilities or limitations has caused hard landings. High density altitude, high gross weight or severe winds are the most common situations. Sometimes confused with simply running out of available power is the vortex ring state. The blade tip vortices strengthen when a helicopter descends vertically into a column of air that is already moving downward. The larger vortices consume power and produce a large drop in rotor efficiency resulting in the pilot’s inability to arrest the descent rate. One of the maneuvers prone to encountering this condition is steep high-power approaches. In Pakistan, it was reported that the temperature was higher than expected and I am sure the helicopter was heavy which could have made for critical power management in a very high stress situation.

Harding landings have been caused by striking an object with the tail rotor in a hover. Several EMS accidents have occurred when the pilot hit a sign, light post or other object while hovering at an off airport scene. Night operations increase the risk of not seeing potential threats. One interesting observation regarding the raid in Pakistan was that the tail rotor assembly was outside the compound wall. Was it blown there from the explosion meant to destroy the helicopter or did it hit the wall on approach causing the hard landing? We may never know.

Regardless of how the hard landing in Pakistan occurred, our military performed a highly successful mission for our country. For that I am thankful and very proud.

  • Kris Sundberg

    I’m glad to see a discussion on this subject. The media reports of “higher than expected temperature” didn’t sound plausible (for a variety of reasons).

    I then heard that the final approach inside the “high walls” of the compound might have caused loss of lift. This also did not seem plausible. Wouldn’t landing in such a confined area actually enhance ground effect?

    The simplest (and I think most logical explanation) is that the tail rotor clipped the wall.

  • alan b.

    Hard landing is just what they told the media. The temp was high and they came in hot and heavy. And they hit that wall. Whether they misjudged and hit the wall and that caused the “hard landing” or if it was something like settling with power or vortex ring state (two different things!), we’ll likely never know.

    Either way, I want to see that helicopter! :)

  • http://www.theflyingfilmmaker.com Brendan Fitzpatrick

    When does a hard landing become a crash? Is there any reason why someone reports hard landing vs. crash?

  • Dan Hester

    I bet the pilot experienced a brown out due to blowing dust inside the compound walls, lost sight of the ground and therefore landed hard with sever damage to the helo, The use of NVGs and landing lights in blowing sand often results in the loss of ground reference resulting in either a hard landing or in a go-around, if the pilot reacts quickly.

  • http://Aopa Pete ayers

    Info I saw locals said lights blinked off and on just before the shots were fired. Makes you thunk they got into powerlines coming in. Too many of those wrapped around the main rotor would be a big reason the leave it.

  • http://www.heliworld.com.au Helicopter Flights Sydney

    Is it a hard landing when the pilot has control and a crash when they don’t?
    What are the guidelines for each?

  • Water Games

    It has every of the essence news so when I take to mean this site that I have been extremely constructive and I assume it very obligatory all group of people.

  • http://www.hiscairo.com/レイバン-サングラス-rayban-ウェイファーラー-rb1079-m3327-jp-6986.html レイバン サングラス

    Getting Traffic Procedure That’s In fact Aiding bag-pros To Expand

  • http://www.kutujpseeru.com/c-89-NIKEナイキ ナイキスニーカー

    The Disgusting Actuality About Your Amazing japan Fantasy